Home / Cherry Grove / Hotels
6 Gay Hotels in Fire Island, NY — LGBTQ+ Friendly Stays
Cherry Grove has 6 gay-friendly hotels listed here — from neighbourhood spots to well-known destinations. Whether you're looking for gay-friendly hotels fire island or something quieter, use the listings below to find your next spot.
Hotels Belvedere
A venetian palace at the beach? Men only? Reserve quickly.
★ 23 ratings
Outdoor Seating Clothing Optional Swimming Pool
Hotels Dune Point Guesthouse
Cozy apartments with kitchens for a more complete stay
★ 10 ratings ·$$$
Outdoor Seating Pet Friendly Hotel
Hotels Grove Hotel
Step into the Ice Palace!
★ 8 ratings ·$$
Outdoor Seating Swimming Pool Hotel
Hotels The Madison Fire Island Pines
Beach house turned guesthouse
★ 4 ratings
Outdoor Seating Bed Breakfast Swimming Pool
Hotels The Hotel Formerly: Hotel Ciel
Step Into The Pines, darlings
★ 6 ratings ·$$
Outdoor Seating Swimming Pool Hotel
Hotels Froot Falls
Landmark gay stay
★ 1 ratings ·$$$
20 Somethings 30 Somethings 40 Somethings
Gay Hotels in nearby cities