Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria
American · European · New York, NY
About
Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria has been serving coal oven pizza since 1987, earning a legendary reputation in NYC's pizza community. BarStool Sports gave their pizza a 9.3, the highest in the city. It's small, gets loud and crowded, but that's part of the charm. The mixed LGBTQ+ crowd and budget-friendly prices make it a great pre-theater spot on 57th Street.
"Excellent brick oven pizza with a crispy crust and great toppings, plus a generously sized antipasti salad."
You can grab a gorgeous glass of wine at the full bar, and they take reservations. It's dog friendly, too. Manager Nick is known for making every visit one-of-a-kind. Go before a show or on a weekend evening when they stay open until 11pm.
Angelo's is located in Times Square, just steps from Central Park and 5th Avenue. It's a busy area popular with tourists and locals alike.
Features
- ✓Coal oven pizza rated 9.3 by BarStool Sports
- ✓Full bar with wine and cocktails
- ✓Dog friendly outdoor seating
- ✓Takes reservations for pre-theater dining
- ✓Budget-friendly prices in Times Square
Cuisine & style
Good for
Practical
What people say
Rated from 1,511 reviews on Yelp · 5 community ratings — we don’t host Yelp’s review text; read the full reviews there.
From the community
Names are kept private and text is lightly edited for clarity.
“The best Pizza we ate in NY”
Excellent brick oven pizza with a crispy crust and great toppings, plus a generously sized antipasti salad. Really enjoy this spot, though it's small and can be noisy and packed.
A visitor · Over a year ago
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria take reservations? +
Yes, they take reservations. It's recommended for busy evenings.
Is Angelo's dog friendly? +
Yes, the venue is dog friendly.
What type of pizza do they serve? +
They specialize in New York style coal oven pizza, with fresh toppings and a crispy crust.
Is there a full bar? +
Yes, they have a full bar serving wine and other drinks.
More Restaurants in New York
Katz's Delicatessen
Restaurants · $$$
Ippudo
Restaurants · $$$
Peter Luger Steak House
Restaurants · $$$$
Brunch Harlem
Restaurants · $$$