Toloache
Latin Spanish · Mexican · New York, NY
About
Toloache is open daily from 11:30am until late, making it a solid choice for a pre-theater dinner or a post-show drink in the Theater District. This two-story Mexican bistro features a guacamole and ceviche bar, a wood-burning oven, and a tequila list that draws a mixed LGBTQ+ and straight crowd for its upscale but unstuffy vibe.
Chef Julian Medina, who opened Toloache in 2007, brings refined Latin cuisine honed at Maya under Richard Sandoval. You'll find outdoor seating when weather permits, and the full bar keeps happy hour lively. Reservations are accepted, which is smart for show nights. The energy stays festive without tipping into rowdy, and the decorative elements imported from Mexico add a genuine sense of place.
Located in Times Square near Broadway and 9th Avenue, Toloache is a convenient stop for Theater District visitors looking for upscale Mexican dining with a lively but refined atmosphere.
Features
- ✓Guacamole and ceviche bar prepared tableside
- ✓Wood-burning oven for signature dishes
- ✓Tequila list with over 100 selections
- ✓Outdoor seating available seasonally
- ✓Happy hour specials weekdays
Cuisine & style
Good for
Practical
What people say
Rated from 2,395 reviews on Yelp · 4 community ratings — we don’t host Yelp’s review text; read the full reviews there.
From the community
Names are kept private and text is lightly edited for clarity.
“excellent”
I really enjoy this spot.
A visitor · Over a year ago
You should order the spicy guacamole. The food and margaritas are excellent.
A guest · Over a year ago
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Toloache take reservations? +
Yes, reservations are accepted and recommended, especially for pre-theater dining.
Is there outdoor seating? +
Yes, Toloache offers outdoor seating when weather permits.
What type of cuisine does Toloache serve? +
Contemporary Mexican with a focus on seasonal natural ingredients, including a guacamole and ceviche bar, wood-grilled dishes, and Latin-inspired plates.
Is there a full bar? +
Yes, full bar with an exceptional tequila list and happy hour specials.
More Restaurants in New York
Katz's Delicatessen
Restaurants · $$$
Ippudo
Restaurants · $$$
Peter Luger Steak House
Restaurants · $$$$
Brunch Harlem
Restaurants · $$$