Fat Witch Bakery
Baked Goods · New York, NY
About
Fat Witch Bakery draws a mixed crowd of locals and tourists, all lining up for brownies that landed on Oprah's Favorite Things list. This Chelsea Market spot has been baking since 1991, using natural ingredients in small batches. They offer 15 varieties, from Caramel to Cherry, plus mini Witch Babies for a three-bite fix. No preservatives, no nonsense.
"Go near closing time and you can grab fat witches for half price."
Go at the end of the day for 50% off leftover brownies. The shop is dog friendly, so you can bring your pup while you stock up. It's a quick stop, not a sit-down cafe. If you're exploring Chelsea Market, you're already a few steps away.
Located in Chelsea, between 15th and 16th Streets, inside Chelsea Market. It's a popular food hall destination.
Features
- ✓Try the Cherry brownie, a fan favorite
- ✓Visit late for half-price brownies
- ✓Buy Witch Babies for a small indulgence
- ✓Order online for individually wrapped gifts
- ✓Stop by Chelsea Market on your way
Cuisine & style
Good for
Practical
What people say
Rated from 470 reviews on Yelp · 6 community ratings — we don’t host Yelp’s review text; read the full reviews there.
From the community
Names are kept private and text is lightly edited for clarity.
“the witching hour”
I admit I'm a bit of a nerd about this. Go near closing time and you can grab fat witches for half price. Delicious. The cherry brownie is amazing.
A visitor · Over a year ago
Frequently Asked Questions
What kind of products does Fat Witch Bakery sell? +
Fat Witch Bakery specializes in brownies, including classic, Cherry, Caramel, Walnut, Blonde, and more. They offer full-size brownies and smaller Witch Babies.
Can I order online? +
Yes, you can order online. Each brownie is individually wrapped and shipped ready to eat or refrigerate.
Is Fat Witch Bakery dog friendly? +
Yes, the shop is confirmed dog friendly.
What are the hours? +
Fat Witch Bakery is open daily from 10am to 7pm.
