NY Pizza Suprema
Pizza · Fast Food · New York, NY
About
NY Pizza Suprema defies the typical quick-slice counter: it's a family-run institution that's been serving pizza since 1964, long before Madison Square Garden moved next door. For its first 24 years, only plain cheese slices were offered — any toppings meant buying a whole pie. Today, it's the only Manhattan pizzeria to earn a perfect score from Slice Harvester's survey of over 370 slice shops, and it's been named one of the best in midtown by Gayot and The New York Times.
You'll find it on the corner of 8th Avenue and W 31st Street, a bustling spot that's family-friendly and dog-friendly too. The vibe is purely casual: grab a slice, sit at a counter, and watch the Garden crowd pour in. If you're near Chelsea, it's a quick walk — and Lombardi's in Little Italy is another classic stop if you're on a pizza tour. There's no fuss, just consistently good pizza from the same Italian family that started it all.
Features
- ✓Dog-friendly casual counter seating
- ✓Open late until midnight daily
- ✓Perfect score from 370-pizzeria survey
Cuisine & style
Good for
Practical
Frequently Asked Questions
Does NY Pizza Suprema take reservations? +
No, it's a counter-service slice shop — no reservations needed.
Is NY Pizza Suprema dog-friendly? +
Yes, the owner lists it as dog friendly.
More Restaurants in New York
Katz's Delicatessen
Restaurants · $$$
Ippudo
Restaurants · $$$
Peter Luger Steak House
Restaurants · $$$$
Brunch Harlem
Restaurants · $$$